How Many Pies for Thanksgiving? Chart by Guest Count

Pie is the one Thanksgiving dish people tend to over-buy or under-bake. Here's a simple rule, a chart for 4 to 30 guests and a worked example for Thursday, Nov 26, 2026.

Setting out the buffet? The Thanksgiving Food Labels printable – $3 has fold-over dish cards with gluten-free, dairy-free, vegetarian, vegan, nuts and spicy tick boxes, plus potluck and leftover labels. Print at home (Letter + A4).

The rule of thumb

• One 9-inch pie cuts into about 8 slices. A deep-dish pie still gives about 8 slices, just bigger ones.
• Plan about 1 slice per guest, then add 1 extra pie if you have 10 or more guests or want leftovers.
• Offer more than one kind once you need 2 or more pies. Many guests take a sliver of two flavors, which uses up about the same pie as one full slice each.
• Count kids as half a slice if there are other desserts on the table.

Pies by guest count

If there are cookies, brownies or a cake too, you can drop about one pie from the "one meal" column. Serving coffee with the pie? Plan about 1 mug per guest and 2 tablespoons of ground coffee per mug: see how much coffee for a crowd.

Which pies to pick

A common mix for 2 or 3 pies is one pumpkin, one fruit (apple or cherry) and one nut or cream pie (pecan or chocolate). If you have a guest with a nut allergy, keep the pecan pie off the same table or skip it, and say so on a label.

Worked example: 14 guests, 3 of them kids

11 adults + 3 kids at half a slice = about 12½ slices, so 2 pies covers dessert. You want leftovers, so make it 3 pies: pumpkin, apple and pecan. Pumpkin and pecan can be baked on Tuesday, Nov 24 and kept in the fridge; apple keeps fine at room temperature for a day or two, so bake it Wednesday.

Making ahead

• Pumpkin and other custard pies: bake up to 2 days ahead and keep them in the fridge.
• Fruit pies: bake 1 to 2 days ahead; they can sit covered at room temperature for about 2 days.
• Pie dough: make it up to a few days ahead in the fridge, or weeks ahead in the freezer.
• Store-bought: check the label for storage, and pick up custard pies from the refrigerated case if that's how the store keeps them.

Common questions

How many slices in a pie? 8 is the usual cut for a 9-inch pie. You can get 10 thinner slices if there are many desserts.

Is one pie enough for 8 people? Only if everyone takes exactly one slice and nobody wants seconds. Two is safer.

How much pie for a potluck? Ask guests to sign up for desserts so you don't end up with five pumpkin pies; the chart above still works for the total.

Plan the oven around the turkey: pies usually need the oven when the turkey does. See how much turkey per person and the turkey thaw calculator. The Holiday Dinner Cooking Timeline Calculator ($5, Excel + Google Sheets) turns dinner time into an oven schedule for each dish. A pen and paper work too.

Labeling the dessert table? The Thanksgiving Food Labels printable ($3) has fold-over dish cards with diet and allergy tick boxes. Labels help guests choose, but they don't guarantee a dish is allergen-free.

Related template: read about the thanksgiving planner 2026 template

See all Cedar & Ledger templates

Try the free cost per meal calculator →